Should dealerships cover tires under warranty?

TekNinja81

Well-known member
Site Supporter
What's up guys?

I posted yesterday after my girlfriend had a tire puncture out in the Peterborough area, looking for anyone nearby who could patch it for us or an open shop to get a new tire. Friends riding with us wound up riding into town to pick up a patch kit from Canadian Tire (only $6!) and we were able to successfully patch the tire well enough to get us back home -- though there still seems to be a slow leak happening we think. Still, it beats what we were quoted to get the bike towed -- $110 + $3.75/km after 10km... would've been over 130km tow, so almost $600 before taxes. ugh.

She called the dealership this morning to find out if there was any sort of coverage for incidents like this, especially given that the bike was purchased less than a month ago and she'd paid for an extended warranty. Unfortunately they could not offer any replacement, or even a discount on a new tire or installation; the warranties don't cover tires so they're really under no obligation to do so. (A blown/damaged tire due to a defect would've been covered apparently, but I'm sure we'd still have to prove it wasn't somehow our fault... either way they said punctures wouldn't be covered.)

Not going to name the dealership as we've generally had very pleasant experiences with them in the past and really don't want to drag their name through the mud. We're just rather surprised at their unwillingness to offer even a discounted price or labour fee this soon after the purchase -- we didn't necessarily expect something for free here, obviously it's not their fault the tire got a puncture, but I've heard of shops being so nice as to waive the labour fee and/or even discount the tire etc in situations like this.

What are your thoughts/experiences on this?
 
LEARN to do things for yourself.....


and get CAA
 
I don't believe they should as tires are a regular wear/tire item. I can see many new owners coming in with dry chains and worn sprockets wanting warranty coverage.

But I'm surprised the dealer didn't offer some sort of discount on the new tire.
 
You cannot demand a "favor" from someone, if the shop decided to help you by giving you a reduced labour rate or a discount on a new tire then it is their decision to do so!

Lol @ dragging their name through the mud...
Anyone with an ounce of common sense would see that you're out to lunch with this one.

Sorry if I sound like a ******, didn't get any sleep last night and I'm working a 12 hour shift today. :p
 
Last edited:
Auto tire manufacturers used to offer a limited warranty on new tires that were punctured/damaged before a certain amount of km. If it was rated for 40 000 km and you got a flat at 5000 km, they would discount a replacement. I can't remember the exact formula, but it was discontinued for whatever reason. Some chain garages offer similar "insurance" but you have to pay for that--it's not a warranty.
 
No, getting a puncture is not the fault of the tire itself. No motorcycle tire is puncture-proof, you can run over a nail anytime.
 
LEARN to do things for yourself..... and get CAA

Not exactly the scope of the message I posted... But thanks anyway.


You cannot demand a "favor" from someone, if the shop decided to help you by giving you a reduced labour rate or a discount on a new tire then it is their decision to do so!
Lol @ dragging their name through the mud...
Anyone with an ounce of common sense would see that you're out of the park with this one.

Like I said, we weren't *expecting* anything free or even discounted, but considering the bike barely has 1000km on it, it was a bit surprising they wouldn't offer anything whatsoever. Yes, tires are a wear & tear item, obviously, but still would've been nice to even offer a 5-10% discount given the circumstances. Actually, we've frequently been given discounts at this dealership because she and I bought our bikes through them, and that's without ever asking for it, so this was a bit surprising.


And like I said, I'm not trying to drag their name through the mud (nor would I accomplish doing so if I were to try), the whole point of my OP was just to ask the question/spark a debate on whether dealerships should offer a limited warranty program for tire problems such as this.
 
No..not unless it's defective in some way.

It would be like asking the dealership to eat some or all of the cost if a rock goes through your windshield. How is that their fault?
 
Last edited:
Firstly the dealership doesn't offer a warranty, the manufacturer does. The dealer only works within the terms of the warranty. The manufacturer is simply warranting that the product is free from manufacturing defects. This is not a manufacturing defect and therefore should not be covered.

Possibly the dealer should or could offer some discount to keep you as a customer if there is a risk of you leaving.
 
Some tire manufacturers offer "road hazard" warranties. That means even if you get a puncture they'll replace the tire. No MC manufacturer does that.

The dealership has no responsibilities for a punctured tire, even on a new bike. They MAY offer a goodwill price reduction on a new tire, which would be nice but I wouldn't thing too much less of them if they didn't. If it was my business I would because I'd want to build the customer's loyalty but it depends on how they see these things. Even if they did offer a discount, I'd probably still find it far cheaper to buy the tires from Pete's and have a shop like Competition Cycle do the installation.
 
LEARN to do things for yourself.....


and get CAA

Learn to do exactly what?
Remove the wheel, change tires at the side of the road with a pen, a paper clip, and no air compressor?

They did patch the tire succesfully when it happened, and then went home. That's a success.
If it was me, I wouldn't even done that much, I had taken the two truck option

OP, do not replace the tire, just patch it with Rosey Toes and continue riding
 
as marcos said, take your bike to rosey toes and get it patched properly ... and if your worried about getting raped on towing charges get CAA plus ...
 
its unreasonable to expect the dealership to do something for you. yes it sucks that it happended to early in the bikes ownership. but you, like everybody else should pay for the patch and move on
 
I'm surprised that they didn't even offer to help out with a discount on a new tire. Every dealer I have purchased a bike from has always given me discounts on most accessories with the sale and some even after the sale. just good customer service and ensures you go back for your next purchase. I would never expect it but......
 
I have a 2005 bike with 95,000km on it and I just bought another FULL 5 year warranty. It has a $50 deductable for all work with unlimited milage. I ALSO bought the FULL tire warranty for 5 years @ an extra $425.00 When my tire gets near bald I call up and get a new tire with installation. (Pirelli Night Dragons) There is no deductable or limited with the tire care. It's not my fault There is always construction where I live.......
Ohhh its also a HARLEY DAVIDSON :rolleyes::rolleyes:
 
whats the point of this post, can't afford a new tire?

With all goods and services, if one retailer is not providing a good price...shop around, doesnt that make the most sense?
 
I have a 2005 bike with 95,000km on it and I just bought another FULL 5 year warranty. It has a $50 deductable for all work with unlimited milage. I ALSO bought the FULL tire warranty for 5 years @ an extra $425.00 When my tire gets near bald I call up and get a new tire with installation. (Pirelli Night Dragons) There is no deductable or limited with the tire care. It's not my fault There is always construction where I live.......
Ohhh its also a HARLEY DAVIDSON :rolleyes::rolleyes:

You bought a 5 year tire warranty for $425?
 
Back
Top Bottom