I went through a similar move away from sportbikes last year, though I was looking at bikes that weren't cruisers (corner clearance!) but had some cruiser vibe around being okay to ride slow. Looked at MT-01's, did briefly consider an XR1200, came very close to a BMW R nineT, and also looked at the Z900. Ended up on a Griso as my best compromise/blend of design, cornering capability, torque, and vibes (both literally and figuratively).
I also didn't want anything ADV, and also thought long and hard about something sport-toury with the emphasis on sport. Have you looked at the Ninja 1000, GSX-S1000 or Tracer 9 GT, or even S1000XR? If you're a sportbike refugee, you may prefer the lighter weight and significant bump in power over the slightly bland NT. Even my Griso, with air-cooling, pushrods and shaft drive, makes marginally more power and torque, with far more character.
There's the R1250RT if like your vibes parallel and your excessive service charges billed in Euros, but if it was my money, I'd be shopping for a Guzzi V100 Mandello. More power, more character, better looks, lighter weight. A friend in California has one, and he's owned literally dozens of bikes over the decades, everything from a CBX to a 1290 Adventure. He says the V100 is his favourite bike of them all.
None of which covers the NT except by comparison. I don't think I've ever even seen one in person, so am only biased from the road tests and podcast discussions I've listened to, none of which are overly flattering. Consensus seems to be the motor is dull and a bit lumpy (a much better fit in the Africa Twin and Rebel), the screen adjustment is awful on the first gen and slightly better on the recent refresh, it's comfy and has decent tank range, but its main raison d'etre is the DCT.