seems like they dont care

Forum Sponsor
I understand where you are coming from. there are cases on this forum where I have recommended certain courses of action to avoid the ticket even though it may theoritically be legal ( such as plate placement). I have to take a day off to fight a ticket too.

What I am saying really is that we can't accurately predict what is going to happen in a cop's head, taking a hand off your handlebars is a very reasonable thing to do and I will not (and will not advocate) not doing something that is perfectly reasonable based on a threat of a misapplied law (because i feel the threat is remote for one thing).

I don't like HTA 172, but i am not going to let it stop me from doing something I know isn't wrong, thats what I am saying.
There is a balance between avoiding hassle and not being paranoid. I am saying that not taking a hand off your handlebars because of 172 is on the paranoid side, not the prudent side.
 
OpenGambit said:
There is a balance between avoiding hassle and not being paranoid. I am saying that not taking a hand off your handlebars because of 172 is on the paranoid side, not the prudent side.
Click to expand...


But being paranoid doesn't mean they aren't out to get me. :D

I do lift my arse off the seat every now and then and I do ride with one hand on the bars routinely. But not if I know a cop is watching.
 
Griffin said:
But being paranoid doesn't mean they aren't out to get me. :D

I do lift my arse off the seat every now and then and I do ride with one hand on the bars routinely. But not if I know a cop is watching.
Click to expand...


Fair enough, I slow down and behave just like everyone else if I know a cop is around. XD
 
OpenGambit said:
meaning that you aren't guilty of careless for letting go of bars... which is exactly my point.

I am still waiting for that cite, until then its just paranoia.
Click to expand...

lol!!
You may not be guilty, but the point is you could be charged!!! There are cases of cops ticketing HTA172 for standing on pegs while going over train tracks. Was taken to court and thrown out as it was not what the law was intended for.
Again, the person was ticketed and charged, but was not convicted.
 
Last edited:
kiwi said:
lol!!
You may not be guilty, but the point is you could be charged!!! There are cases of cops ticketing HTA172 for standing on pegs while going over train tracks. Was taken to court and thrown out as it was not what the law was intended for.
Again, the person was ticketed and charged, but was not convicted.
Click to expand...

Still not seeing a cite.
 
What exactly are the infractions by the other motorists, there? "Kicking up rocks by pulling over on a soft shoulder"? "Left turn too close to motorcycle"?
 
Griffin said:
I think he's looking for you to reference a specific case so that it can be verified. i.e. not just rumour.
Click to expand...


or trolling..
 
I am not the one spreading falsehoods about tickets you can't get for taking a hand off your bars.

the standing on pegs was a myth by the way, so this is pretty much on the same level.
 
wteff had no idea it was "illegal" to ride with one hand . . . will keep that in mind and cut down on resting my left arm my leg lmfao
 
You just proved my point.

Lots of wannabe lawyers but no ticket.

This kind of garbage rumor milling is the reason why a bunch of people on this board cry all the time about how reasonable some laws are.

no facts, just tons of awful arguments and rallying against problems that don't exist.
 
Last edited:
Griffin said:
Good points and I do agree with you. Unfortunately though, even being ticketed is a major pain in the *** for most of us, whether we prove our innocence in court eventually or not. I've won every ticket I've contested but it still cost me at least a day's work if not more each time.

My point with HTA172 is that it's language is so broadly applicalbe that a cop can pretty much use it for anything they don't like. As noted by a previous poster, Careless is more probable to be misused in this circumstance.

With respect to your opinions and insights, which I value, I think the problem for many of us is not "what does the law say" (although for HTA172 I do have a problem with what it says) it's "what is the cop gonna do with the law".
Click to expand...


I don't think the cops ticket you hoping to land a conviction. You may declare victory after the trial, but that cop just got paid overtime for sitting around in a court room all day long. Win or lose, they win. That's the point. This is why you see cops making 100k a year. I'd love to see any other profession that doesnt require anything more than a high school education pay an easy 100k a year with pension and benefits. Pigs.
 
daisoman said:
Maybe he had bigger fish to fry? Dunno but those weren't major infractions.
Click to expand...
Speeding is less dangerous than making a turn in front of someone or driving off the road but I bet if he had added another 5-10 kph to his speed he would've gotten pulled over. Why do they only care about speeding (rhetorical question)??
Forum Sponsor
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom