Suspect over $1k for the AT leaving $700 and change for the KLR. I know you can’t ride them both full time but, doesn’t seem out of line. I think I’m around $800 for a 2012 Bonnie at replacement cost of $5k.
Not sure what the multi bike owners do to keep insurance costs down or, they have a broker/agent on speed dial to swap out as needed? When I had the 2 BMWs, it was just over a grand for both but, 1 was full coverage and the other was fire and theft only as I only intended to ride one. Can’t remember the breakdown of cost for that time.