I have had my 919 fail to start twice within a month. First time I yanked the battery, fully charged it up on a CTEK charger, put it back in, rode it, then let it sit a week or two. It just barely failed to start both times (turning over but not lighting off). Yanked it again, charged it again, then got Parts Source to test it on a Midtronics EXP-800. The tester measured the battery temperature at -40C so I think its measurement of 170ish CCA is optimistic, but even though I took it off the charger that morning it measured a voltage of 12.43, when it should have been ~12.8.
FWIW it's a YTZ-10S and I think it's pitifully undersized for the bike, but I'm not really happy with only getting 5 years out of it. I paid a hair over $200 for it after tax, thinking that a getting a genuine Yuasa battery would minimize the problems with it being small. The bike is a "spare" and does not get a lot of use, but I do still ride it once in a while, and take the battery out every fall and rotate it on the same CTEK charger. Now I'm wondering if I should just save my money and get something dodgier. What do you think?
FWIW it's a YTZ-10S and I think it's pitifully undersized for the bike, but I'm not really happy with only getting 5 years out of it. I paid a hair over $200 for it after tax, thinking that a getting a genuine Yuasa battery would minimize the problems with it being small. The bike is a "spare" and does not get a lot of use, but I do still ride it once in a while, and take the battery out every fall and rotate it on the same CTEK charger. Now I'm wondering if I should just save my money and get something dodgier. What do you think?