So this has been on my mind pretty much as soon as I got my bike earlier this year. So it seems like the general recommendation you find anywhere is you should start on a 250/300 unless:
- You have previous riding experience
- You know you're gonna be doing a lot of highway
But I think there should be a third (and possibly a 4th) criteria:
- if you live somewhere where there are nothing but flat, straight roads near you
- and possibly, if you've driven fast manual transmission cars before
So before I took my M1x course earlier this year, I had never ridden a motorcycle. I did my course, picked up my new (to me) motorcycle and started commuting on it the very next day. I felt pretty comfortable being on a motorcycle and in traffic, so I decided I'd go the trial by fire way instead of putting around in parking lots. And I think within 2-3 days of picking it up, I started to realize I might've made a mistake. Now I'm not saying I'm a good or bad rider, I know I have A LOT to learn. I know that, but that doesn't change how underwhelmed I felt. This is where that 4th point I made comes in - I've always been a car guy and been fortunate enough to drive some fast cars here and there. I know most cars can't even keep up with a SS, but a 500+HP car makes a 300 feel like you're in slow motion.
Now when I've actually had the bike out on some curvy roads, it's a blast. Kawasaki did a terrific job making a bike that's so easy to ride and confidence inspiring even for a new rider like myself.
But the reality is, I live in the middle of Toronto. That means I have to go out of my way and plan in advance to find any decent roads that aren't just completely flat and straight. I commute on my bike daily from Toronto to Markham, so 95%+ of my overall riding is done on straight roads. And with how fast modern family cars are nowadays (and how lead footed some drivers can be), I can't even pull ahead at a light to change lanes or whatever without winding the N300 up a decent amount. I'm not going to complain about how the bike feels on the highway since that's not what the bike was designed to do so it would be silly to complain about it.
So with that all said, I think the geography of where you're going to be doing the majority of your riding should be a bigger factor in choosing what kind of bike to get. I wish I started on something a little bigger.
EDIT: Yes I'm a newbie, I only have a month under my belt. But am I the only one to think that geography should be considered?