Wow thanks guys for all the responses! I'm still up in the air, and will definitely miss it. But if I barely have time to ride, paying the insurance seems silly, and keeping the bike in storage for 1-2 years (or more) may not be the best thing for the bike...but I haven't really researched it yet.
Will see in the next few weeks if it goes up for sale, as it may be time to try something new regardless. I do like the look of the new Honda Rebel 500...as they look the right size for me. Small cruisers are great. Love the HD Iron 883 but haven't really seen much in the 5k price range....maybe the Yamaha Bolt...that one looks cool and have read decent reviews about it also.
Thanks again!